- Western vs. Eastern: a comparison – Science of the Stars
- Report Abuse
- Difference between Vedic Astrology & Western Astrology
- Why Hindu Astrology Is Predictive Astrology
- How can Western Astrology and Vedic Astrology both be correct?
They demand a starting point which is defined by the area of the moon when a child is born.
This matches the beginning of Aries and interests in sections of 30 degrees for the signs that occur after that. Western astrologers practice distinctive types of appearances.
Western vs. Eastern: a comparison – Science of the Stars
It involves the five Ptolemaic aspects that are connection, sextile, square, trine, and action. These are in tight orbs of 10 degrees or less, defined by the sort of aspect. Planets only aspect other planets and the angles Ascendant and Midheaven. In western astrology, the smaller the orb the stronger the aspect. Hence, a planet in Libra is in regard to any planet in Aries, no matter what their degree areas are. Unlike Western astrology, where the kind of appearance adds meaning. Vedic aspects are indeterminate. What performs an aspect positive or negative is not the type of character however whether the aspecting planet is benefic or a malefic.
The benefit planets are Jupiter, Venus, and also Mercury and the Moon. If we see that someone is going to be experiencing a lot of grief and turmoil in the future then we can reasonably predict they will probably lose a loved one or suffer some kind of tragedy. Thus the tropical chart can at least predict with some accuracy future events and can delineate with great accuracy personal details of our character. This is by no means all that it is confined to, but it is where I have always seen it excel.
Hence where a western astrologer may predict grief in the future, a jyotishika is much more likely to predict the cause of the grief such as loss of a loved one and be able to delineate exactly which loved one will be lost and why.
In other words it appears that the western school is very good at dealing with our subjective reality and feelings while jyotish excels at dealing with the actual events and karmas objectively, regardless of how we will personally react to them. Hence it is common for many westerners to find a jyotish reading to be rather impersonal and cold in its dispensation of raw facts and events.
Having given my ideas as to the differences between the two systems and how they tend to be approached, I will now try to illuminate how this comes into play for explaining the differences between the tropical and sidereal signs. The tropical zodiac is seasonal and thus relies completely on the Sun. However the stars could care less what season it is and remain fixed, and since the light of the stars is the harbinger of our karma the sidereal zodiac is specifically karmic and deals with actions and events that are going to happen regardless of what we think or feel about them.
Thus even though in a western chart the Sun in Sagittarius aka the energies of the 3rd month of Autumn may lead to a happy, friendly and benevolent if not mischievous kind of person, in the sidereal chart the Sun in Scorpio could give a military father, sharp features to the body, some health issues, etc… depending on the aspects affecting it. Sun Signs vs. Moon Signs West vs.
- Vashikaran Specialist in Melbourne.
- daily horoscope 26 october 2019?
- Vedic vs. Western astrology means differences in practice.!
The use of the Sun sign system and its emphasis in the West is much more like the calendrical-based astrology of China than it is jyotish. Hence it is not Leo that is giving them the traits of the so-called Sun-sign, but it is actually just the energy of the season. For Aries would certainly give a hotter summer than Leo, and Cancer a cooler winter than Capricorn! So the names of the zodiacs are being used simply as place-holders in the western system, and we should actually understand that the mechanism of sun-signs is the energetic effect that the particular season has upon all those who are born in it.
In fact many western astrologers would benefit from studying the Chinese calendrical system to better understand the subtle variations of the seasons and how they effect us. Thus we should understand that those born in spring will be more boisterous generally than those born in fall, and those born in summer more physical and extroverted than those born in Winter.
Difference between Vedic Astrology & Western Astrology
Jyotish actually has a similar system in place, and many astrological texts give long lists of attributes for being born in the different seasonal months, days and ever hours! It also has a 60 year cycle similar to the Chinese calendar that likewise has various traits assigned to each year. In Jyotish the most commonly used tool for understanding the psyche of a person is the Moon, which is said to be the karaka indicator of the Mind.
Instead of relying too much on the zodiac signs for analyses the nakshatras or lunar mansions are used.
Why Hindu Astrology Is Predictive Astrology
Each of them give a distinct effect on the personality primarily, and then the moon receives the influence from the zodiac sign it is in secondarily and then any other aspects it may be receiving thirdly. Thus a person born in Krittika nakshatra may be a natural leader but be a slave to his or her desires and perhaps even abuse power, especially being in the Taurus part of the nakshatra wherein material desires become much stronger. If Mars were to aspect the Moon alongside this favorably then a good Chandra-Mangala yoga would form giving the native the energy to succeed in the missions they set out to do and they will always being trying to manifest their lofty ideas Jupiter into the world Taurus.
In such a way with other considerations taken into account a learned astrologer will determine personality in a very accurate and scientific way and be able to deduce not just the personality but also some major life events.
How can Western Astrology and Vedic Astrology both be correct?
Traditionally the vedic method is not as exact or worried about orbs of influence or degrees whereas the western schools consider aspects according to exact degrees. A good aspect is an aspect from a good planet, a bad one is from a bad planet. Unlike Western astrology, which gets a lot of flak for being more wrong than right, Vedic astrology has a documented reputation for being accurate.
Witness accounts have said that it predicted major life events such as having emergency surgery, a change in career and one man who practiced Vedic astrology even predicted his own death to the minute. Follow Us. Sign in. Photo: unsplash. Jesse Oakley.